The one question SYRIZA needs to answer

Agora Contributor: Yiannis Mouzakis
Photo by MacroPolis
Photo by MacroPolis

With the coalition in Greece getting only 160 votes for its presidential candidate in the first ballot, falling short even of the most conservative estimate, based on the currently available information it seems that the number of deputies that will vote in favour in the third round on December 29th will not reach the minimum 180 required.

In this set of circumstances, national elections seem inevitable and all developments with regards to concluding the latest troika review will be put on hold, including the receipt of over 7 billion euros in disbursements. These include 1.8 billion euros from the EFSF, around 2 billion euros of SMP profits and 3.5 billion euros from the IMF.

The fact that the debate in Greece over the last few days has been relegated to cheap bravado and threats of an economic collapse should not allow tangible issues that require clear answers to be ignored.

The latest polls point towards a SYRIZA win and a government led by the leftists. The fact that they have expressed their intention to re-negotiate the agreement with the troika raises a serious issue for Greece's funding over the period and until negotiations with Greece's creditors are settled. Being so close to the top job, Tsipras should explicitly outline how he plans to deal with the financing challenges that his government is expected to face.

Greece has been running a primary surplus in 2013 and this year, which means that it is capable of meeting basic obligations relating to public sector wages, pensions and state operations. The primary surplus for 2014 is expected to be just over 3 billion euros, at 1.8 percent of GDP.

Although this is a spectacular turnaround from the primary deficit of 25 billion euros in 2009, the figure is not sufficient to give the country complete autonomy to service debt obligations.

Next year Greece is scheduled to repay 8.4 billion euros to the IMF, just short of 6 billion in total interest payments, bonds held by the ECB and other eurozone national central banks (NCBs) worth 6.7 billion euros at the end of July and August plus 300 million of other bond and senior note maturities.

This is over 21 billion euros of debt obligations and forms a pretty sizable funding hump that will need to be addressed irrespective of who is in power.

Based on this year's repayment schedule, the IMF received by March about 1/5 of its scheduled payments. This rose to more than half by August. Assuming a similar pattern next year, Greece will need approximately 1.5 billion euros by March and 4.5 billion euros by August for IMF first programme repayments.

Based on the 2015 budget, interest payments during this period will reach 2.2 billion euros by March, 3.4 billion at the end of June and exceed 5 billion euros by September.

On a quarterly basis, for IMF and interest payments alone Greece is expected to need 3.8 billion euros by March, 7.1 billion by June and 10.9 billion by the end of September. The ECB/NCBs maturities are 3.5 billion euros on the 20th of July and 3.2 billion on the 20th of August.

The current government's baseline scenario, which does not include national elections, to deal with those financing needs is to conclude the review by end of January, receive the disbursements, agree the precautionary credit line (ECCL) and hope that political normality will calm markets or, if not, go to the fallback position of relying on ECCL.

In contrast, a SYRIZA-led government will have to deal with a programme extension that will be expiring in a matter of weeks from its formation, no disbursements and no fallback solution of a credit line. It is also fair to assume that Greece would not have regained market access. It is in this environment that the new administration would be launching an effort to change Greece's programme conditions, potentially including debt relief measures.

Irrespective of whether Greece’s creditors would be willing to engage in such discussions, SYRIZA would have to deal with sizeable debt servicing obligations in a very tight financing space.

The funding cushion of borrowing from the cash reserves of government organisations via short term repos seems to have been exhausted, according to the latest government bulletin which shows that 5.8 billion euros has already been used up.

Based on this year's data from the Bank of Greece, although most months have run a primary surplus, which will give SYRIZA a small cash cushion, March saw a sizeable primary deficit of just under 1 billion euros. The cumulative primary cash position to September was around 2.8 billion euros  and no more than 2.4 billion in July.

Provided that SYRIZA has no intention of adopting any new fiscal measures to raise revenues or cut spending in 2015, even if the budget execution is not impacted by the uncertainty of the unfinished negotiations, the primary surplus in the first half of 2015 will be nowhere near the 7.1 billion euros needed for IMF and interest payments. It is not even enough to cover the 3.4 billion euros of interest payments by the end of June.

The maturities of bonds in July and August seem to place in front of SYRIZA a hard stop, allowing just enough time for its government to be left to stew before it is forced to concede under the pressure of a potential default on the bonds held by the ECB.

Wanting to re-negotiate aspects of Greece's programme and insist on the debt relief the eurozone had agreed to are justifiable policies and would in many respects be welcome. But doing so without a clear plan or strategy is an accident waiting to happen.

Follow Yiannis: @YiannisMouzakis

4 Comment(s)

  • Posted by: Dean Plassaras

    This latest crisis about the pseudo-elections for the inconsequential president is a cheap game 100% engineered by Berlin. Greece has ceased to have a government really as of 2012. The Syriza folk are of course complete amateurs and financial ignoramuses. Therefore both the 180 votes will be found somehow and all this commotion and agitation are completely unnecessary. The sad part is that Greece is a certified German colony and it's following blindly a path to disaster because the Beast of Berlin seems to be the most ignorant and malicious of all actors in this fabricated drama.

    Reply You have to
    in order to reply.
  • Posted by: Anonymous

    Unfortunately I can not read Greek to see if they promise without any (hidden) conditions ...

    But I could imagine that a few days after election - the first talks with Troika ending in chaos - their page says that due to "higher forces" they deeply regret that they must adapt their plan to new conditions....

    Reply You have to
    in order to reply.
  • Posted by: H.Trickler

    >"Irrespective of whether Greece’s creditors would be willing to engage in such discussions, SYRIZA would have to deal with sizeable debt servicing obligations in a very tight financing space."

    Debt servicing obligations are much easier (close to zero) if Greece declares bankruptcy and changes to Drachma.

    Reply You have to
    in order to reply.
    • Posted by: Greek_pragmatist

      Yes but their platform includes staying in the Euro. If they go back on that promise Tsipras will be leaving Greece one day soon in a helicopter off of the roof of the Vouli!

Please Comment

You have to
in order to add a comment.